Copycat Carrabba's Grill Seasoning Recipe (2024)

A slam dunk grill seasoning that works on chicken, fish, beef and pork! This Copycat Carrabba’s Grill Seasoning is the best one ever!

Sometimes I get a hankering for a meal I’ve eaten at a favorite restaurant, does that happen to you? Well a few weeks ago, I was craving Carrabba’s Chicken Bryan, and set out to make our family this beautiful dish.

Chicken Bryan is a perfectly grilled seasoned chicken breast with a delicate, but oh-so-flavorful lemon butter sauce, topped with soft and melting goat cheese and chopped sun-dried tomatoes. Personally I think it’s best served with rustic mashed potatoes, but also delicious with pasta or fresh steamed broccoli.

Recipe for Chicken Bryan coming soon, but in the meantime, I wanted to get this amazing grill seasoning in your kitchen, it’s delicious on everything!

How to use a grill seasoning rub

1. My favorite is as a Grilled Chicken Seasoning, sprinkle 1 ½ – 2 teaspoons all over your chicken before you grill.
2. Use like you would Montreal Steak Seasoning; sprinkling and rubbing on steaks, ribs and even hamburgers.
3. Consider using as a BBQ Rub, rubbing on flank steaks, skirt steaks, steaks, even pot roasts, and chuck roasts.
4. FISH! Let’s not forget fish, sprinkle a little on your favorite fish before pan frying, grilling, baking or broiling.

A LITTLE SEASONING GOES A LONG WAY

I have to tell you a story, I made this grill rub a few weeks ago and my husband asked if he could help prep for dinner, I said, “sure, if you could sprinkle a little of the grill seasoning onto the chicken breasts, that would be great.”

I had my back turned preparing another portion of our dinner and turned around to see more than have the jar of grill seasoning gone!

“Eeks, honey, sprinkle a ‘little‘” I said, he laughed and said, “Oh I thought you wanted the entire jar on the chicken!”

We got a good laugh out of that, I scraped some off, and didn’t salt the sauce at all, we had a few pieces that were pretty salty, but overall it turned out fine. Just remember a little goes a long way.

INGREDIENTS NEEDED

• Kosher Salt | Salt isthe foundation of any goodruband shouldmakeup about half of your mix. Not onlydoesit add flavor, but it also pulls moisture from the outer part of the meat. This allows you to develop a seared crust, whichwillhold the rest of the moisture in leaving your meat juicy. (Source)
• Freshly Ground Black Pepper | anyone who knows me, knows I typically steer clear from black pepper, but a spice rub is one place I typically put it in, I’ll be honest and say I don’t usually put as much as is called for, but fresh ground is definitely best!
• Granulated Garlic | Granulated vs. Garlic Powder, they are really the same thing, but granulated is a bit more coarse, like cornmeal, you can use either one. I also added a teaspoon of Rinaldo’s Toasted Garlic, the little nuggets of freshly toasted, all natural garlic you see in the mix!
• Granulated Onion | You can use onion powder or granulated; spoiler alert, I actually used Trader Joe’s Onion Salt, great to make dips, on eggs or in this case in a rub!
• Dry Oregano | A traditional Italian herb used in many Italian seasonings, be sure it’s fresh! Crumble a little in your hand and do the sniff test before using, it should smell like oregano.
• Crushed Red Pepper | even if you are a spice wimp (like me!) please put in the crushed red pepper, it’s a tiny bit, but adds tremendous flavor!

HOW TO MAKE GRILL SEASONING

Are you ready? It’s a bit complicated….NOT!

Simply measure, dump, stir to mix and store in a airtight container, I love these Half Pint Jars! (Psst, also great for Golden Milk Spice Mix and Anti-Bacterial Hand Scrub!)

HOW MUCH SEASONING DO I USE?

• CHICKEN | General rule of thumb is 1 tablespoon per 1 pound of chicken. Be sure to rub the dry rub on all sides of the chicken. Leaving on no longer than 4 hours, preferably placing on just prior to grilling your chicken.
• BEEF | Useaboutonetablespoon for every pound ofmeat.You canapply arubright beforeyoucook or a few hours ahead of time for basic grilling or upto24 hours ahead ifyou’re smoking the meat. Try it on these Air Fryer Steak Tips!
• PORK | Same rule as above, great on pork loin, roast, chops, shoulder, sprinkle and cover the hunk o’ meat.
• FISH | Start by drizzling on a little bit of olive oil or avocado or other quality vegetable oil, then sprinkle on the rub a little at a time, you won’t need as much as the other cuts of meat. Grill or prepare as normal.
• VEGGIES | Sprinkle on mushrooms, stir fry and other vegetables.

Great Host (or Hostess) Gift!

Know people who love to cook and grill!? This grill seasoning makes a fabulous hostess or host gift! Place in a pretty jar with simple instructions on how to use and the contents. Check out these other great hostess food gifts as well!

• Lemon and Peppermint Hand Scrub
• Fall or Christmas Simmering Spices
• Homemade Vanilla Extract or Bourbon Vanilla Extract
• Easy Teriyaki Sauce and Marinade
• Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice

Don’t forget to PIN to your favorite Condiments & Seasoning’s Board!

Recipe adapted from Carrabba’s Italian Grill Recipes from Around Our Family Table Cookbook.

Print this FREE Ingredient Substitution Chart
Click Download button below.